Benchley Contracting & Rental Corp

Active

USDOT 1136863InterstatePRIVATE PROPERTYOperating since Jun 2003MCS-150 last updated 2 yrs agoUpdated Apr 21, 2026

Call Message

Strong safety record

Benchley Contracting & Rental Corp is an active interstate carrier based in Forestville, NY.

Not Rated

No FMCSA Compliance Review on file.

0.0%

OOS Rate · below 21% national

BASIC Alerts · of 5 categories

Crashes · last 24 months

0Power Units4 drivers

0Total Drivers4 CDL

0Inspectionslast 24 months

0Violations1.0 per inspection

0%OOS Ratevs 21% national avg

0Crasheslast 24 months

Company Details

Phone: (716) 934-4330
Email: benchleycrane@gmail.com
Address: 11437 Bennett State Road
Forestville, NY 14062
Officers: Cornelius R Benchley, Jason D Jagoda

Operation: Interstate
Classification: Private Property
Cargo: Construction, Large Machinery
Hazmat: No
Drivers: 4(4 CDL)
Mileage: 87386 mi (2024)
MCS-150 Updated: May 7, 2024
Safety Rating: None
Crash Rate: 0.00 per million mi

Insurance

No insurance filings on record.

View on FMCSA L&I

Carrier Profile

Annual mileage: 87,386 mi(2024)
Fleet: 8 power units· 4 tractors · 25 trailers · 4 trucks
Drivers: 4 drivers(4 CDL · 2 interstate · 2 intrastate)

Mailing address: P O Box 220
Forestville, NY 14062
Fax: 7169343290

Fleet Details

Vehicle Type	Owned	Term Leased	Trip Leased
Straight Trucks	4	0	0
Tractors	4	0	0
Trailers	25	0	0
Total Power Units	8

Equipment Observed

Last seen Mar 18, 2026

Distinct vehicles · 24 mo

vs 8 self-reported (MCS-150)

Top makes

PETERBILT1
UNPUBLISHE1

Registered in

BASIC Analysis

Higher values = more violations. 0 = clean record.

Category	Insp w/ Viol

How this carrier compares

Cohort: NY · All carriers

Category	vs. Cohort	vs. State	Reading
Unsafe Driving	0%	0%	Better than most peers
HOS Compliance	0%	0%	Better than most peers
Driver Fitness	0%	0%	Better than most peers
Controlled Substances	0%	0%	Better than most peers
Vehicle Maintenance	57%	84%	Around peer average

Lower percentile = lower SMS measure = stronger safety record. Computed nightly across active carriers in the same state and fleet-size band.

FMCSA Registry Timeline

First registered: Jun 2003· 23 years ago
Last MCS-150 self-update: May 2024· 2 years agoStale
Authority status: Active

Inspections (24 months)

Last inspection: Mar 18, 2026 · 4 months ago

Type	OOS %	Nat'l Avg
Driver	—	6.67%
Vehicle	—	22.26%
Hazmat	—	4.44%

Where they run

Inspected in 1 state. Top state NY accounts for 100% of activity. Activity outside home state (NY): 0%.

Accident Reports (24 months)

Period	Fatalities	Injuries	Tow-away	Total
No crashes recorded	0	0	0	0

Violation Details

Most-cited violation codes

39395A3Emergency Equipment - Fire Extinguishers - no visual indicator1x
39395FEmergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper1x

BASIC Category	Total	Severe	OOS
Vehicle Maintenance	2	0	0

Recent activity · last 3 inspections, 2 violationsShow details

Recent Inspections

Date	State	Vehicle	Violations
Mar 18, 2026	NY	STRAIGHT TRUCK	0
Oct 1, 2024	NY	STRAIGHT TRUCK	2
Jun 27, 2024	NY	TRUCK TRACTOR	0

Recent Violations

Date	Code	Description

Similar Carriers Nearby

Andrew J Graff

No alerts

Forestville, NY · 1 units

Anthony J Tofil

No alerts

Forestville, NY

Anthony Richter

No alerts

Forestville, NY · 1 units

Arthur E Dolce

No alerts

Forestville, NY · 2 units

Bailey Manufacturing Co Llc

No alerts

Forestville, NY · 1 units

Try DataTruck — AI-Native TMS

Unsafe Driving	0	0.00	—
HOS Compliance	0	0.00	—
Vehicle Maintenance	1	0.80	—
Driver Fitness	0	0.00	—
Controlled Substances	0	0.00	—

Oct 1, 2024	39395A3	Emergency Equipment - Fire Extinguishers - no visual indicator	Vehicle Maintenance	—
Oct 1, 2024	39395F	Emergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper	Vehicle Maintenance	—